Government rows back on £38k family visa earning threshold hike
Ministers have rowed back on plans to hike the earning threshold Brits need to bring foreign family members to live in the UK to £38,700.
Instead, the government has confirmed plans to increase the threshold to £29,000 in the spring.
Home Secretary James Cleverly had announced the increase from £18,600 to £38,700 as part of a package of measures to curb legal migration.
It came after the Office for National Statistics (ONS) revised its net migration figure — the difference between the number of people arriving in the country and leaving — to put 2022 at a record of 745,000.
But the move attracted criticism as it threatened to tear families apart, with many having their future thrown into doubt as the government considered the details of the policy.
Home Office Minister Lord Sharpe of Epsom confirmed the change of plans in answer to a written parliamentary question on Thursday.
The minister said that the current threshold of £18,600 allows 75 per cent of the UK working population to bring their foreign family members into the country to live.
He added that increasing the threshold to £38,700 would limit the same right to 30 per cent of the working population.
Lord Sharpe said: “In spring 2024, we will raise the threshold to £29,000, that is the 25th percentile of earnings for jobs which are eligible for Skilled Worker visas, moving to the 40th percentile (currently £34,500) and finally the 50th percentile (currently £38,700 and the level at which the general skilled worker threshold is set) in the final stage of implementation.”
The minister said the threshold would be “increased in incremental stages to give predictability”.
However, no date for when the threshold would rise beyond £29,000 was given in Lord Sharpe’s answer, nor did one appear in Home Office papers published on Thursday detailing the plans.
The Prime Minister previously told MPs the government was looking at “transitional arrangements” for changes to the thresholds to make sure they are “fair”.
In a factsheet detailing its plans, the Home Office confirmed that changes to the family visa scheme would only apply to new applicants.
Anyone granted a fiancee visa before the minimum income threshold is raised will also be assessed against the £18,600 requirement when they apply for a family visa, rather than the new threshold.
The home secretary suggested the plans would still reduce net legal migration by 300,000 people a year.
Cleverly said: “Today, I have provided further detail about how these measures will be applied and when they will be introduced.”
He added: “This plan will deliver the biggest ever reduction in net migration, with around 300,000 fewer people coming to the UK compared to last year, delivering on our promise to bring the numbers down.”
In a letter to MPs on Thursday, Home Office Minister Tom Pursglove said the changes would be introduced in a “stepped fashion throughout early 2024”.
He said: “We believe that this strikes the right balance between the immediate need to start reducing net migration and giving those affected adequate time to prepare for upcoming changes.”
The Liberal Democrats suggested the £38,700 threshold had always been “unworkable”.
The party’s home affairs spokesman Alistair Carmichael added: “This was yet another half-thought-through idea to placate the hardliners on their own back benches.
“James Cleverly needs to put down the spade and stop digging. Decisions like this should be made by experts and politicians working together.
“He should also publish the advice from the Treasury and OBR (Office for Budget Responsibility) about the impact that his package of changes will have on the economy.”
Shadow Home Secretary Yvette Cooper meanwhile said the change was “more evidence of Tory government chaos on immigration and the economy”.
She added: “Net migration has trebled as skills shortages have got worse – and they still have no proper plan to link the immigration system to training or workforce planning.
“They failed to consult anyone on their new proposals and took no account of the impact of steep spousal visa changes on families next year, so it’s no surprise they are now rowing back in a rush.”
Initial reaction from the Tory right to the change did not appear positive.
Jonathan Gullis, a Conservative former minister, wrote on X: “Legal migration to the UK is too high and unsustainable. That is why the government was right to introduce tough and necessary new measures to get numbers down and demonstrate control of our borders.
“This decision is deeply disappointing and undermines our efforts.”
Press Association – David Lynch