Minority Game: What stock investors can learn from the failure of Black Friday
Black Friday has come and gone, but the massive surge of shoppers which was anticipated in much of the media failed to materialise. Many retail outlets were quieter than a normal Friday. In contrast, internet shopping went wild. Amazon had its biggest ever day in the UK, selling over 7m items. Argos and John Lewis experienced problems with their websites because of the huge number of visitors. For the first time ever, online sales are believed to have exceeded £1bn in a single day.
Experiences such as this raise fundamental questions about the predictability of many social and economic events. The Office for Budget Responsibility handed George Osborne an extra £27bn to play with in his Autumn Statement by revising its forecasts through to 2020. Many commentators have pointed to the large amount of uncertainty which surrounds them. But these are predictions over a five year horizon. Even just a week ago, many believed that the shops would be packed on Friday. The retailers themselves geared up for the crush, but it did not materialise.
It is always possible to rationalise an event after it’s happened. In an Asda store on Black Friday 2014, shoppers trampled each other and fights broke out as they attempted to grab bargains. This mayhem was publicised widely. Looking back, surely it is obvious that this is why people went online rather than risk a repeat of last year’s chaos? In fact, so-called hindsight bias appears to be deeply rooted in our individual psychologies. Something happens, and we often come to believe that it was inevitable. But this is not what the retailers and the media thought in advance of last Friday. We conveniently forget that we failed to predict it even the day before.
Approaching Black Friday, consumers were essentially playing something called the Minority Game. You want to go shopping, but not if there will be huge crowds. If the shops are empty, however, it is not enjoyable. Like baby bear’s porridge, you want it just right – not too many, and not too few. Parisians leaving the city for their annual month off in August face a similar problem. Giant traffic jams have been experienced at 3am in the morning, as everyone came to the view that the roads would be quiet at that time. In stock markets, the ideal time to sell is just before the point when majority opinion shifts from being bullish to bearish. You are in exactly the right size of minority.
Two Swiss physicists, Damien Challet and Yi-Cheng Zhang, formalised the structure of the game about 10 years ago. Since then, literally thousands of scientific papers have been written about it. The problem can be stated in words very simply, and it is one with many practical applications. But even using hair raising maths, it turns out to be fiendishly difficult to solve. In general, there is no strictly rational way to play the game. To succeed, you need to adapt your strategy constantly but the overall outcome is highly uncertain, just like Black Friday.