Can You Ever Forgive Me? film review: Melissa McCarthy shines in this odd-couple heist movie

The normally jovial Melissa McCarthy completely transforms herself to play Lee Israel, a New York biographer who finds a new stream of income forging personal letters from famous writers of the past.

It’s a fascinating premise (adapted from the real life Israel’s 2008 memoir), playing out as a simple but well executed heist movie. The dialogue crackles with sardonic put downs and toe-curlingly awkward social interactions.

What makes it special, however, is the character study. Israel is portrayed as a surly, bitter human being who’s the sole architect of her decline. Despite this, you desperately want her to succeed, with McCarthy unearthing a vulnerability hiding within the misanthropy. Israel displays the insecurities and fears we all feel, only her character uses a less effective mask. McCarthy has never been finer, bringing something to the role that even Julianne Moore – formerly in the running to play the part – couldn’t have provided.

The film also has a secret weapon in Richard E Grant’s Jack Hock, a faded Manhattan socialite now drifting between drugs and younger men. He becomes Israel’s drinking buddy and sidekick, with the film’s finest moments coming from their scenes together. Grant gives Hock a desperate chirpiness, convinced that the many problems in their lives will be solved by one more round. It’s a delightful surprise from the actor, which may kick off a much-deserved career renaissance.

For those a little tired of McCarthy’s wacky comedies, Can You Ever Forgive Me? is a showcase for the dramatic abilities of the two-time Oscar nominee, backed up by Grant’s finest performance since Withnail and I. A bittersweet gem that celebrates society’s misfits, it’s more than worthy of its many accolades.